When Pope Francis died in April 2025, the cardinal electors entered one of the most unpredictable conclaves in modern Church history. Many barely knew one another. Almost nobody thought an American could become pope.
Veteran Vatican journalist Gerard O’Connell, co-author of The Election of Pope Leo XIV: The Last Surprise of Pope Francis, joins Vatican Access to unpack the hidden dynamics that shaped the conclave that elected Cardinal Robert Prevost as Pope Leo XIV.
Drawing on deep reporting and conversations with cardinals close to the process, O’Connell explains how Prevost quietly emerged from under the radar, why Cardinal Parolin’s candidacy collapsed, the role Francis himself may have played in preparing the ground for Leo’s election, and how the new pope is already beginning to shape the future of the Catholic Church.
In this conversation, we discuss:
The secret pre-conclave tensions over Pope Francis’ legacy
Why many cardinals believed an American pope was impossible
How Cardinal Prevost rose rapidly during the voting inside the Sistine Chapel
Whether Leo represents continuity or change from Pope Francis
Why Gerard O’Connell believes Leo may become one of the world’s strongest moral voices on war, inequality, and global division
This is a conversation about power, faith, history, and the election of a pope at a moment when the Catholic Church — and the world — are searching for unity.


